Name: Trump Is Taking Away Transgender Healthcare Protections Created Under Obamacare
Brand: buzzfeednews.com
SKU: buzzfeednews-com-225
Availability: OnlineOnly

critic

Trump Is Taking Away Transgender Healthcare Protections Created Under Obamacare

preview

AdvertisementThe Trump administration further stripped away protections for the LGBTQ community Friday by allowing health providers to deny service to transgender people.The would narrow the scope of the ACA’s Section 1557, which bans discrimination based on race, color, national origin, sex, age, and disability in health programs that receive federal funding.In 2016 the Obama administration tried to extend protection to trans people by changing the definition of discrimination by sex to include “one’s internal sense of gender.” That rule has been tied up in the courts.The Trump administration’s new rule removes gender identity as a form of sex discrimination. This means HHS will not punish healthcare providers or insurance companies that discriminate against patients simply for being transgender — nor will the agency have any regulation saying that sort of discrimination is illegal.The regulation, first proposed as a in May 2019, limits the way discrimination “on the basis of sex” is defined in healthcare settings.The new rule also provides a blanket exemption to health providers who refuse to provide abortion services because of their religious beliefs.AdvertisementUnder the 2016 rule, such exemptions would be considered on a case-by-case basis where religious beliefs were weighed against other factors. An analysis by the Kaiser Family Foundation found that this change means people in need of abortion services could be denied, delayed, or discouraged from seeking necessary care, placing them at risk of serious or life-threatening harm in emergency cases where a person has limited access to healthcare providers.NARAL Pro-Choice America released a statement calling the rule change an “unconscionable” move to strip LGBTQ people of protection from healthcare discrimination.“This rule will hurt Americans and fall hardest on people who already face barriers to accessing healthcare,” the group said. “The cruelty of this administration knows no bounds.”Although the new regulation reflects the administration's opinion about the scope of antidiscrimination law, specifically concerning sex, it does not prevent a victim from suing in court. Transgender plaintiffs have prevailed in numerous recent sex discrimination lawsuits involving education and workplaces.When the draft rule was released, critics vowed to challenge the final rule in federal court — so lawsuits now appear likely.Since Trump’s first months in office, his administration has taken to legalize discrimination against LGBTQ people and limit reproductive rights — including even when state laws prohibit it. Often, the administration has invoked the notion of “” to advance these aims, contending moral objections trump federal nondiscrimination protections and allow people to circumvent state civil rights laws.AdvertisementIn its latest regulation, HHS is asserting that bans on sex discrimination should be interpreted narrowly, which the Justice Department is also arguing in .When Congress passed the Affordable Care Act in 2010, lawmakers included Section 1557 to establish nondiscrimination protections in healthcare services and insurance by referring to Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 and other civil rights laws — but it left the specifics up to future rule-making. HHS under then-president Barack Obama fleshed out those details in a 2016 regulation that asserted Title IX’s ban on sex discrimination included discrimination on the basis of gender identity and termination of pregnancy.The rule essentially prevented medical workers, insurers, or organizations from discriminating against transgender patients for any services — including transition-related care — and against women who have had or are seeking abortions in some circumstances.A federal judge had at the end of 2016, and shortly after Trump took office, his administration announced plans to rewrite it.Pertaining to abortion care, the 2016 nondiscrimination clause applied only when a health insurer or organization provided the same types of procedures for both abortions and nonabortion services. For example, a procedure called “dilation and evacuation” is used both in miscarriage care and abortion care. If a Catholic hospital provided this service for miscarriages, for example, it would also have to provide it for abortions.The rule affected the vast majority of healthcare workers because it applied to any hospitals, doctors, or clinics that accept federal reimbursement or remunerations, like Medicare or Medicaid payments. It also affected insurance companies that participate in the health insurance market.AdvertisementA group of states led by Texas, joined by several organizations, sued the Obama administration in a remote Texas district with only one presiding judge, who blocked the rule, so it never took effect. After Trump took office, HHS indicated that it would reverse the regulation in order to make the lawsuit moot.The dispute is at the heart of a much larger national debate over what “sex” means: sex as identified by birth, gender identity, or other factors.Many conservatives have insisted that if lawmakers intended for sex discrimination laws to address transgender people, they would have written such language explicitly into the bills, as they did in the Violence Against Women Act.“When Congress prohibited sex discrimination, it did so according to the plain meaning of the term, and we are making our regulations conform,” Roger Severino, director of HHS's Office for Civil Rights, said in a statement in May 2019 about the draft rule. HHS added in a that the rule is “returning to the government’s longstanding interpretation of ‘sex’ under the ordinary meaning of the word Congress used.”But several courts have found that federal bans on “discrimination because of sex” cover bias over sexual orientation and gender identity as forms of illegal sex discrimination. For instance, several federal courts have ruled that trans people endured bias because their gender identities differed from their sex at birth, or they didn’t conform to gender stereotypes for someone of their birth sex.The Trump administration, however, narrowed its definition of “biological sex” in March 2019 when the Defense Department released a policy . The policy defined “biological sex” as a “person's biological status as male or based on chromosomes, gonads, hormones, and genitals."AdvertisementAdditional reporting by Ema O’Connor.Dominic Holden is a political reporter for BuzzFeed News and is based in New York.Contact Dominic Holden at .Paul McLeod is a politics reporter for BuzzFeed News and is based in Washington, DC.Contact Paul McLeod at .Got a confidential tip?AdvertisementCommentsUnable to load comments.Try reloading this page or{{^ results }}There are no comments yet.{{/ results }}{{# results }}{{#blurb}}{{ blurb }}{{/blurb}}{{#picture_url}}{{/picture_url}}{{/ results }}{{# count }}{{/ count }}Show moreClose this modalWe, and our partners, use technologies to process personal information, including IP addresses, pseudonymous identifiers associated with cookies, and in some cases mobile ad IDs. This information is processed to personalize content based on your interests, run and optimize marketing campaigns, measure the performance of ads and content, and derive insights about the audiences who engage with ads and content. This data is an integral part of how we operate our site, make revenue to support our staff, and generate relevant content for our audience. You can learn more about our data collection and use practices in our Privacy Policy.If you wish to request that your personal information is not shared with third parties, please click on the below opt out button. Please note that after your opt out request is processed, we may still collect your information in order to operate our site.Opt OutContinue without Opting OutWe and our partners use technology such as cookies on our site to personalize content and ads, provide social media features, and analyze our traffic. Click below to consent to the use of this technology across the web. You can change your mind and change your consent choices at anytime by returning to this site.I do not acceptI acceptShow purposesThe storage of information, or access to information that is already stored, on your device such as advertising identifiers, device identifiers, cookies, and similar technologies.The collection and processing of information about your use of this service to subsequently personalise advertising and/or content for you in other contexts, such as on other websites or apps, over time. Typically, the content of the site or app is used to make inferences about your interests, which inform future selection of advertising and/or content.The collection of information, and combination with previously collected information, to select and deliver advertisements for you, and to measure the delivery and effectiveness of such advertisements. This includes using previously collected information about your interests to select ads, processing data about what advertisements were shown, how often they were shown, when and where they were shown, and whether you took any action related to the advertisement, including for example clicking an ad or making a purchase. This does not include personalisation, which is the collection and processing of information about your use of this service to subsequently personalise advertising and/or content for you in other contexts, such as websites or apps, over time.The collection of information, and combination with previously collected information, to select and deliver content for you, and to measure the delivery and effectiveness of such content. This includes using previously collected information about your interests to select content, processing data about what content was shown, how often or how long it was shown, when and where it was shown, and whether the you took any action related to the content, including for example clicking on content. This does not include personalisation, which is the collection and processing of information about your use of this service to subsequently personalise content and/or advertising for you in other contexts, such as websites or apps, over time.&lt; Back&lt; BackSee full vendor list

AdvertisementThe Trump administration further stripped away protections for the LGBTQ community Friday by allowing health providers to deny service to transgender people.The would narrow the scope of the ACA’s Section 1557, which bans discrimination based on race, color, national origin, sex, age, and disability in health programs that receive federal funding.In 2016 the Obama administration tried to extend protection to trans people by changing the definition of discrimination by sex to include “one’s internal sense of gender.” That rule has been tied up in the courts.The Trump...

public

Dominic Holden

Got something that needs 👀? Send us tips here:   http://tips.buzzfeednews.com. Support our reporting: http://bit.ly/2VkE9pK

Trump Is Taking Away Transgender Healthcare Protections Created Under Obamacare

No article scores yet.

CRITIC REVIEWS

PUBLIC REVIEWS