Name: Tim Scott Is Proposing a Major Reform to Qualified Immunity
Brand: reason.com
SKU: reason-com-492
Availability: OnlineOnly

critic

Tim Scott Is Proposing a Major Reform to Qualified Immunity

preview

Sen. Tim Scott (R–S.C.) has reportedly proposed a compromise to rein in qualified immunity, the legal doctrine that makes it difficult for victims to sue government officials when their constitutional rights have been violated.Scott, who has served as the Republican leader on police reform talks, is suggesting that the doctrine be pulled back for law enforcement and that liability shift from individual cops to the departments that employ them. As of this writing, it was not immediately clear if the plan would curtail qualified immunity or outright eliminate it. (Qualified immunity protects all public officials, though this move would likely apply solely to police officers.)Legislated into existence by the Supreme Court, qualified immunity currently requires that any misconduct alleged against state actors be outlined almost exactly in a previous court precedent should the victim want the right to bring his suit before a jury. Such a thing often doesn't exist. Qualified immunity has thus protected a cop who , two cops who allegedly while executing a search warrant, a cop who during a bogus drug search, two cops who for standing outside his own house, and a cop who , among others."[Democrats] have been as responsive in this recent conversation than they have ever been, in my opinion," Scott CNN, noting that the discussion is "on the verge of wrapping soon."Some progressives have pushed back on the idea, according to the network, instead insisting that individual officers be held accountable personally. That's misguided. As I've previously , police departments already finance the vast majority of payouts when a police officer is not granted qualified immunity and subsequently loses a lawsuit in his or her professional capacity."Sen. Tim Scott's proposal—requiring the city to bear the costs of these suits, instead of officers—would make transparent what already happens in over 99 percent of cases," Joanna C. Schwartz, a professor of law at the University of California, Los Angeles and an expert in qualified immunity. "We absolutely need to find ways to increase officer accountability—by, for example, changing union protections that make it difficult to fire bad officers."The GOP has historically resisted change on this issue. After the death of George Floyd sparked a national conversation on issues of police misbehavior and accountability, the issue of qualified immunity went from an obscure doctrine discussed in legal and academic circles to something the majority of the American public now reforming. Former Rep. Justin Amash (L–Mich.) a bill to eliminate the doctrine for all government officials and achieved tripartisan support—though with only .Sen. Mike Braun (R–Ind.) his own proposal to curb the doctrine, but withdrew it after Fox News host Tucker Carlson him for it and after the law enforcement lobby made its known. Former President Donald Trump said that reform on the issue would've constituted an automatic veto, and Scott himself said last summer that it would have been a "poison pill."But a few states have picked up the mantle where Congress has refused to act.&nbsp;The New York Times that legislators are studying reforms in Colorado, which a law last summer allowing people to bring claims against police officers in state court. and have greenlit similar pieces of legislation.Virginia also mulled such reforms. Lawmakers eventually the idea after encountering opposition from a group of predictable dissenters: police unions.

Sen. Tim Scott (R–S.C.) has reportedly proposed a compromise to rein in qualified immunity, the legal doctrine that makes it difficult for victims to sue government officials when their constitutional rights have been violated.Scott, who has served as the Republican leader on police reform talks, is suggesting that the doctrine be pulled back for law enforcement and that liability shift from individual cops to the departments that employ them. As of this writing, it was not immediately clear if the plan would curtail qualified immunity or outright eliminate it. (Qualified immunity protects...

public

Billy Binion

Reason is an American libertarian monthly magazine published by the Reason Foundation. The magazine has a circulation of around 50,000 and was named one of the 50 best magazines in 2003 and 2004 by the Chicago Tribune. Reason was founded in 1968 by Lanny Friedlander (1947–2011), a student at Boston University, as a more-or-less monthly mimeographed publication. In 1970 it was purchased by Robert W. Poole Jr., Manuel S. Klausner, and Tibor R. Machan, who set it on a more regular publishing schedule.

Tim Scott Is Proposing a Major Reform to Qualified Immunity

No article scores yet.

CRITIC REVIEWS

PUBLIC REVIEWS