Name: Stefanik voted yes on the Equality Act in 2019. Why does she oppose it now?
Brand: timesunion.com
SKU: timesunion-com-28
Availability: OnlineOnly

critic

Stefanik voted yes on the Equality Act in 2019. Why does she oppose it now?

preview

WASHINGTON — U.S. Rep. Elise Stefanik was one of a handful of Republicans to vote in favor of an gay, lesbian and transgender rights bill in 2019, and as recently as Tuesday she she was for the measure again.But on Thursday afternoon, when the Equality Act returned to the House floor, the Schuylerville Republican cast a vote against the legislation, although the text of the bill had not changed substantively from two years ago.Stefanik on Friday declined to comment to the Times Union on why she changed her vote. The one other Republican who switched his vote cited concern for religious groups and individuals.The Equality Act amends the 1964 Civil Rights Act to explicitly ban discrimination against people based on sexual orientation and gender identity in sectors including housing, employment, federal programs and public accommodations such as stores and even websites. It builds on and codifies a June &nbsp;that found the Civil Rights Act protects LGBTQ people from employment discrimination. The legislation also makes clear that religious freedom cannot be an excuse to challenge the law's protections.The bill passed the House 224-206 on Thursday, with all Democrats and three Republicans — Reps. John Katko and Tom Reed of New York and Brian Fitzpatrick of Pennsylvania — voting in favor.Senate Majority Leader Charles E. Schumer, D-N.Y., has promised to bring the bill to the Senate floor "at exactly the right time," but it's unclear if the legislation will be able to win 10 Republican votes in that chamber to block a filibuster. President Joe Biden supports the measure.Stefanik was one of eight Republicans who voted yes on the bill in 2019, including Katko, Reed, Fitzpatrick as well as&nbsp;Susan Brooks of Indiana, Mario Diaz-Balart of Florida, Will Hurd of Texas, and Greg Walden of Oregon. Brooks, Hurd and Walden subsequently retired from Congress, leaving Stefanik and Diaz-Balart the only two Republicans to switch their votes this week.Rep. Jeff Van Drew, R-N.J., identified as a Democrat and voted in favor and co-sponsored the Equality Act in 2019. But since then he has changed his party — and he changed his vote to a no this year, too.In a statement to CNN, Stefanik said she thought discrimination based on sexual orientation was wrong but was concerned about the Equality Act's impact on single-gendered organizations and sports.Diaz-Balart said in a statement that he voted for the bill last Congress but pointed out what he thought were "severe flaws" that needed to be fixed.Most Popular"House Democratic Leadership had ample time to make these changes, but sadly, they ignored multiple good faith efforts by my colleagues and instead doubled down on some of the most troubling issues, including sabotaging religious freedom," he said. "Despite its name and promise to eliminate discrimination, what the bill actually does is discriminate against mosques, churches, and religious organizations for their deeply held religious beliefs."Diaz-Balart said he would introduce alternative legislation that would protect both LGBTQ people and religious entities from discrimination.When the Equality Act passed the House in 2019, there was no hope that the Senate would pass the bill or President Donald Trump would sign it. But things have changed with a Democratic-controlled Congress and president, although Republicans still maintain significant power in the 50-50 Senate.Conservative and religious groups have once again come out against the bill, applying pressure on Republican lawmakers.Earlier this week, conservative groups including the Heritage Foundation, Family Research Council, Family Policy Institute and Save Women's Sports held a to lobby against the bill, calling it the "most dangerous piece of legislation to come out of Congress" and claiming the legislation would sanction abortion, introduce "explicit content" in schools and allow "males" to win girls' sports championships and enter girls' locker room, an apparent reference to transgender people.The Human Rights Campaign — the nation’s largest LGBTQ civil rights organization — celebrated the legislation's passage by the House, calling it "a major milestone for equality bringing us closer to ensuring that every person is treated equally under the law.""In most states, a person can be denied housing, education or the chance to serve on a jury because of their sexual orientation or gender identity," said U.S. Rep. Paul Tonko, D-Amsterdam. "It’s dead wrong."Top Picks In ShoppingMost PopularTop shopping picks

WASHINGTON — U.S. Rep. Elise Stefanik was one of a handful of Republicans to vote in favor of an gay, lesbian and transgender rights bill in 2019, and as recently as Tuesday she she was for the measure again.But on Thursday afternoon, when the Equality Act returned to the House floor, the Schuylerville Republican cast a vote against the legislation, although the text of the bill had not changed substantively from two years ago.Stefanik on Friday declined to comment to the Times Union on why she changed her vote. The one other Republican who switched his vote cited concern for religious...

Stefanik voted yes on the Equality Act in 2019. Why does she oppose it now?

No article scores yet.

CRITIC REVIEWS

PUBLIC REVIEWS